home
Shri Datta Swami

 Posted on 09 Dec 2018. Share

Caste-system: Manmade or God-made?

Discourse Podcast

O Learned and Devoted Servants of God,

[Dr. K. V. Prasad (USA) asked:- In Gita God Krishna said in a verse “chaaturvarnyam...” that He is responsible for the caste system and yet, not responsible for it. What is the meaning of this mutual contradiction?]

Swami replied:- In this verse the upper two lines say “Originally, I have created the caste system based on qualities and deeds” (Chaatuvarnyam...). The word ‘Srushtam’ indicates the beginning stage of the creation or Srushti. The two lines below of this verse say “even though I am responsible for this caste system, yet, I am not responsible for this” (tasya kartaaramapi maam...). On careful analysis, we can resolve the mutual contradiction seen in this verse, which is that God is responsible and yet, not responsible for the caste system.

In the beginning of creation, God created the caste system based on the classification of qualities and deeds. Souls interested in preaching the spiritual knowledge in the society were called as Brahmanas. Souls interested in fights for keeping justice protected were called as Kshatriyas. Souls interested in business for the distribution of commodities were called as Vaishyas. Souls interested in agriculture and public service were called as Shudras. Since the qualities and their subsequent professional works are the basis of the caste system, the caste is not decided by birth, but, by the possessed qualities and their corresponding expressed deeds. Anybody born to anybody can come under a specific caste. One gets the caste based on his/her interest and acquired qualities and deeds related to the specific interest. God says that He is responsible for such original caste system based on qualities and deeds.

In such case, why God said that He is not responsible for the caste system? The word caste expressed here is not the same caste system expressed above, which is based on qualities and deeds. What He means exactly is that He is responsible for the quality—deed based caste system, but, He is not responsible for the birth based caste system that appeared in due course of the creation due to misunderstanding. If He means that He is the establisher of quality based caste system and at the same time He is not responsible for the same quality based caste system, the self-contradiction is inevitable here leading to the conclusion that God is mad! Since God can never be mad being omniscient, it shall mean a different type of caste system that evolved later on for which He is saying that He is not responsible. The evolved new caste system is based on birth only and not on qualities and deeds. This means that the evolved caste system means that the issue of a Brahmana shall be Brahmana only irrespective of qualities and deeds of that issue. What is the reason for the evolution of such new caste system based on birth in course of time? There is a valid reason. A quality is always imbibed by the child from the surrounding atmosphere. The atmosphere of a Brahmana family is congenial to get the qualities and deeds corresponding to a Brahmana. Moreover, the parents are also very much interested in inducing their qualities into their child. Hence, the soul imbibes the qualities of Brahmana from its parents from the childhood itself and this appears as if that a Brahmana generates another Brahmana only. This is a coincidence that makes us to think that as if a Brahmana generates another Brahmana through genes carrying the qualities from parents to child. But, this is totally wrong since genes carry certain mannerisms only and not the qualities. Qualities are always imbibed by the soul from the surrounding atmosphere only and the qualities appear in a soul from its childhood from the congenial atmosphere of the family. The qualities and the interest on such qualities are developed by such congenial atmosphere of the family, which misleads us to think that a caste generates the same caste through the blood relationship. This is a general tendency based on the existence of natural congenial atmosphere.

The above concept of congenial atmosphere continues to mislead us to think that the caste system is based on the birth and blood relationship only and this is valid as long as the system continues. But, when there is a break in this continuing system, the analysis is required to find out the basic truth. In such situation, the basic truth comes out, which is that the caste system is based on the imbibed qualities and corresponding deeds only and not based on the birth and blood relationship. Bhuurishrava is born in the family of pot makers or Shudras. But, he became a terrible Vedic scholar and his surrounding atmosphere of his family, which was not at all congenial to such special quality, could not influence him to develop interest in preparing the mud pots. Such special qualities appear in a soul based on his background in the previous birth, which are very strong and not effected by any different atmosphere even though such atmosphere exists in its house from its childhood. These strong qualities were imbibed by the soul from the then surrounding atmosphere in the previous birth. Brahmanas in that time were sages, who know the basic true concept and hence, elected Bhuurishrava for the post of the presiding authority (called Brahma) in a sacrifice performed by them in Naimisha forest. The sages were powerful scholars of the truth and were never misled by the superimposed concept of caste system by birth. They did not reject Bhuurishrava as Shudra believing the caste by birth. Sage Gautama selected Satyakaama Jaabaala as Brahmana to teach spiritual knowledge to him based on his quality of speaking truth following the caste system created by God based on qualities since his biological father was not known. Sage Raikva called Janashruti born to Kshatriyas as Shudra since he was much worried about materialism only (Shudra means the person, who is always worried about the materialistic path only and this is based on the root verb ‘Shuk’ meaning worry). This again shows that sage Raikva followed the caste system based on qualities only.

God says that He is the establisher of the original caste system based on qualities and deeds. He further says that He is not the establisher of the subsequently developed new caste system by misled souls based on birth. The contradiction in this verse is solved.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

 
 whatsnewContactSearch
Share Via