15 Aug 2025
[Swami, my atheistic friends are asking the below questions. Please enlighten my friends through Your divine wisdom. – Ms. Thrylokya]
Part-1 Part-2
Part-2
8. Please enlighten on the following argument.
[Swami, the same friend asked “If God had not allowed the first sin to happen, there would have not been a first victim-soul, who suffered for no fault on its side. Therefore, God becomes the reason for the first sin, which is the root cause for the subsequent bad actions. When God does not allow the fresh case of sin, there would have been no retort case at all. By allowing the fresh case, God is also allowing retort case. Instead of this, He can prevent the fresh case by saving every victim so that no retort case appears”. Please enlighten her, Swami.]
Swami replied:- God is not allowing the sin. He advises again and again not to do the sin. God has given full freedom called free will to the souls. God says many times that if you do sin, you will be punished and if you do merit, you will be rewarded. Due to the free will given by God to the souls, it appears like God is allowing the sin. This is your illusion that leads to perfect misunderstanding. The first sin happened when God told Adam and Eve not to eat a specific fruit, but, on the advice of Satan, Adam and Eve ate that fruit breaking their word given to God. Satan is nothing but their free will based on individual sinful nature. In this sin, Adam and Eve are sinners only and none of them are victims. Victim is the innocent soul, who suffers for no mistake. Both Adam and Eve are not victims here since they could have waited without touching that fruit with full faith on God because the same God would have told after some time to enjoy that fruit also when they become deserving.
The Gita says that the cycle of deeds and fruits is very complicated like a three-dimensional network (Gahanā karmaṇo gatiḥ…). In this network, several promoting factors and opposing factors with their limitations appear, which sometimes cancel each other and sometimes, cannot cancel each other etc., making the whole network very very complicated for logical analysis. If the victim is very much deserving, God will prevent the fresh case by protecting the victim and for this, the example is that Draupadi was protected by God Krishna, who gave infinite number of saris to Draupadi. God prevented the fresh case of the sin and fully protected Draupadi by saving her from the situation of becoming naked before the entire court of King Drutarashtra. God helps the victim (deserving victim by prevention and mixed victim by cure) as per the merit only and not because the victim asked for help or because the victim is a devotee of God. If you take ordinary souls having less deservingness (it is a mixture of deservingness and undeservingness), the judgement of God is not prevention but cure. This means that in such mixed case, the fresh case allows the fresh crime to take place and subsequently allows the retort case so that the mixed victim can punish the criminal of the fresh case. Here, the criminal of the fresh case is also a mixed soul so that he/she is also allowed with mixed fruit.
9. What about the souls who don't want to get bonded with both the world and God?
[Swami, another friend asked “Every prayer to God in every religion is full of praises to God, which proves that God likes to be praised. Moreover, God is advising in the Gita that one can break the justice for His sake and get salvated from worldly bonds. What about the souls, who don't want to get bonded with both the world and God? God made Himself as the only option to get liberated from worldly bonds, which again proves His monopoly over souls”. Please enlighten him.]
Swami replied:- God has no need to have fascination for the praises from souls. Moreover, the greatness of God is so high that all the water in the oceans will perish if you take it as ink and start writing about His greatness and at the end, His greatness still remains untold completely. All the angels, several sages and energetic beings of other upper worlds constantly praise God. Compared to the number of upper worlds, earth is simply one sub-world. In fact, God is bored with the praises of uncountable energetic beings. God wants to reform the middle level human beings since they are neither upper angels nor lower demons and are always of half knowledge. Angels do not require upliftment. Demons can never be reformed. Human beings always create hope for the upliftment due to their semi-angel nature.
Your allegation of monopoly on creation by God is a thorough misunderstanding due to your half-knowledge. The sages, who are also the souls of highest order, have created all the ethical and spiritual scriptures. God tries to help the souls, who follow these scriptures and there is no force of Nivrutti (Spiritual life) on any soul. God only has the ultimate expectation about Pravrutti (Justified worldly life) so that all souls can live happily with peace in the world. Nivrutti is the path in which all the worldly bonds are broken for the sake of God. When a soul tries to enter Nivrutti, God puts several tests and discourages the soul to enter into Nivrutti. You are talking as if God is craving for devotees. All this is the biggest nonsense that is created in your devilish mind.
10. Can the soul suffering throughout life be considered for mercy killing by God?
[Swami, another friend asked “There are many souls, who suffer continuously throughout their life. Can’t those souls be considered for mercy killing by God?” Please enlighten her.]
Swami replied:- There is no endless pessimism for any soul. If the soul develops faith in God and patience in suffering difficulties, there will be some type of betterment in the future, which is inevitable. To give maximum enjoyment to the soul, the most benevolent God arranges the fruits of merits and the fruits of sins in an alternating way violating the sequence of merits and sins actually done by the soul. Without caring the sequence of timings in which the deeds are done, God rearranges the life cycle of every soul with alternating fruits of merits and sins just like arranging sweet and hot dishes alternately in the meal. God is the Father of all souls and He always tries to uplift the soul. God cannot harm the soul in anyway even if the soul wishes for it. God’s bitter punishments in hell show only His intensive love on His children to reform them even through bitter ways. Such harshness is only love and not anger or hatred. The parents take their child to hospital and get it injected with medicine because they want the child to recover as early as possible. The child may cry due to pain during the injection of the medicine, but, they allow the child to cry for the welfare of the child only. When a boy or girl is addicted to drugs, the parents tie their child with iron chains in the house, provide all the medical treatment and give food with affection every single day. This is to be seen as the most sincere love of the parents and not as vengeance. After recovering from the bad addiction, the same child will appreciate the parents and praise their true love. But during the process of treatment, negative thoughts against parents are very common because the fault of misunderstanding lies with the child. God, the Divine Father, also forgives the child-soul and feels happy that the soul has returned to normal justified life leaving the sinful thoughts and deeds. Whatever may be the situation, one must never misunderstand God because if we misunderstand Him and stop praying to Him, we will only lose His help and there is absolutely no loss for the omnipotent God.
11. Does God grant soul to exit from creation?
[Swami, he says “God will not remove any soul from His creation because God loses His entertainment if everyone opts out. Even if the soul sincerely begs God or does serious penance for getting rid of this cycle of birth and death, God will not grant its exit from creation because God gets bored with loneliness again without souls”. Please enlighten him, Swami.]
Swami replied:- This is like telling that the doctor will not cure the patient so that the patient will continuously visit the doctor and pay the fees continuously! This is like telling that the advocate will not allow the party to win the case so that the party will continuously pay him the fees! This is like telling that the teacher will not allow the student to pass the examination so that the student will join the class again and again and pay the fees continuously! What a crooked mind you have!! You, the atheist-beast! How dare you talk like this about the most noblest and the most purest God? I think even the eternal liquid fire in the special hell headed by Kaalabhairava is incapable to punish your sin!
God always helps the soul to get rid of the cycle of birth and death. This means that the liberated soul will be having birth and death in this world without getting entangled with the fascination for worldly bonds. Such liberated soul will be accompanying God during His incarnations, assisting God in His divine mission that is helpful for the world of devotees.
12. Please enlighten on the following argument.
[Swami, he says “If ever I worship, I want to worship a higher entity above God called ‘Super God’ to save my soul from both the world and God. There will not be any mention of such entity in any religious scriptures because all the scriptures are from God only and every powerful entity including God says that there is nobody greater than itself.” Please enlighten him, Swami.]
Swami replied:- God is the terminal of the endless chain of causes and corresponding effects. If there is Super God above God, that Super God is the end of the chain. We call such Super God as God because God Himself is the supermost ultimate link of the endless cause-effect chain. I think it is far better if you join a mental hospital for some time to set right your mind. You are neither a complete theist nor a complete atheist. You accept the existence of God and rub bad intentions on God towards His created souls. I am getting vomiting hearing your questions. You are neither male nor female. The very meaning of God as per our intention and analysis is that God is the most holiest and the most purest personality.
13. Please enlighten on the following argument.
[Swami, I told him about the story of how Draupadi was helped by God Krishna due to her sacrifice of piece of sari without aspiring anything from God when Krishna was in need of a bandage for His cut finger. He said, “God has given freedom to every soul to do any sin, which made every soul open to face violence or rape from any other soul. Now, every soul is definitely in need of protection from the omnipotent God because every soul is little potent, which cannot protect its family or children or its own self. To get protection from God, we need to pay Him some price (Karma Phala Tyaaga or sacrifice of fruit of work) as Guru Dakshina. To attain permanent union with God since all worldly bonds are temporary, we need to sacrifice everything for Him as a price for it. It is like big companies (God) monopolising the markets (souls) by first creating a demand for their product (God’s grace) and pricing it as they like”. Please enlighten him, Swami.]
Swami replied:- i) In the beginning of creation, God controlled every soul. But, the souls, acting like robots got bored and prayed God for some freedom. God was misunderstood as a dictator in that time. God gave freedom to the souls and is advising what is good and what is bad for every generation by coming as human incarnation. When the freedom is given, the soul is responsible for its action and has to be rewarded for its merits and has to be punished for its sins. This is not the crooked plot of God to cheat the souls.
ii) Souls loved God for protection. God preached the souls that true love does not aspire any fruit in return. God also told that mere theoretical love is not true love because practical love is the proof of true theoretical love. This concept is very well seen in the worldly life also. God is fully satisfied since He is omnipotent. There is no need for God to receive any help from any soul. The Karma Phala Tyaaga (sacrifice of fruit of work) is a proof for true theoretical love. If a person is in need of help from the public and preaches for Karma Phala Tyaaga, it can be treated as cheating. When God is omnipotent and not in need of any help from any side, how can you say that this is cheating? Perhaps, you are blaming God to throw mud on God for which the root reason is that you are greedy. If you don’t like this sacrifice, don’t do it. Who is begging you?
iii) You have compared God to a business man. God Himself is condemning business devotion (Vaishya Bhakti). In the example given by you, the product is advertised very much and its price is fixed at a very high level. This is business exchanging of a product with money. In Karma Phala Tyaaga, the concept is to sacrifice for God without aspiring anything in return. How can your example suit to this concept?
14. Please enlighten on the following argument.
[Swami, I told him about how Krishna tested the spouse-bond of Gopikas by dancing in Brundaavanam and created Goloka for successful Gopikas liberating them from all the worldly bonds permanently. He commented “God Vishnu is the husband of Goddess Lakshmi. God Krishna is God Vishnu. God being a married man conducts the test of spouse-bond for other married ladies and encourages them in sweet devotion so that He finally becomes the permanent husband/darling to the successful souls in the upper world. It looks like He is not happy with His own wife and wants to get more wives/darlings as diversity in His entertainment. What if a higher being comes and conducts the same spouse-bond test to His wife to liberate her from God?” Please enlighten him, Swami.]
Swami replied:- You have taken God just equal to a human being and the Gopikas, who were sages and who did penance for God for millions of previous births, also as ordinary human beings. You have built up the story treating God as one romantic human being not satisfied with His wife and the sages as ordinary married human beings, who were also fond of illegal sex. Let us assume that God and sages are human beings only as per your dirty imagination. In your novel, you must remember that the Gopikas prayed God for romantic dance and God advised them strongly to go back to their homes. Then, the Gopikas threatened God that they will commit suicide by jumping into Yamuna River. Then only, God danced with the Gopikas. These points are deleted in your wonderful novel for the sake of convenience of your argument. You told that let somebody also test the wife of God to liberate her from the bond of God. In fact, your proposal also was a true incident only. The wife of God called Mahaa Lakshmi born as Sita was very much tortured by Ravana, who was daily requesting her to leave her husband, Rama and become his queen. Ravana was higher than Rama in terms of richness and can be treated as a higher being as told by you. But, Sita was prepared to commit suicide and was not yielding to Ravana. In this way, you cannot blame God in any angle. I think, you will now shut up your mouth in all angles! You cannot explain even a tiny miracle being performed by God at present in Hindupuram of Satya Sai District in Andhra Pradesh (From the foot of a small marble statue of Shirdi Sai, water has been flowing continuously since many months and gallons of water have flowed so far) and you are mocking about God in a foolish way like this!
15. Please enlighten on the following argument.
[Swami, another friend asked “When the original God is unimaginable and nothing can be known about Him except that He exists, what is the proof that God has only good intentions for souls? What is the proof that God doesn’t have bad intentions?” Please enlighten her.]
Swami replied:- All the existence of positive information and all the absence of negative information regarding God is very very clearly explained by the topmost devotees called sages in various divine scriptures in all the religions across the world. Learning true spiritual knowledge is called as the first step of Jnaana Yoga, which means knowing all the details about God that answers all the questions of all types of devotees so that every devotee is fully aware of even the minute details of the divine personality of God. In every generation, God comes as the contemporary human incarnation and proves the truth present in all the divine scriptures. Jesus told “I have come to fulfill what is said in the scripture”. When such a clear theory supported by practical evidence exists, what better proof you want? You will not ask for more proof unless you are the patient escaped from a mental hospital!
16. Please answer on the following argument.
[Swami, the same friend asked “God said the Veda. The Veda says that God is the greatest. It means God Himself is declaring that He is the greatest. Even the role of wife of God is played by God Himself. It means that He is obsessed with His own self. But, on the contrary, God preaches all souls to overcome self-obsession and love God for the sake of their own welfare. Does it not show His double standards?” Swami, please answer him.]
Swami replied:- When God told that He is the greatest, it is perfect truth and there is no trace of exaggeration in this point. God did not praise Himself in anyway. If you say that you are a man, is it called as self-obsession? He advised souls not to praise themselves because even a trace of praise of any soul is not truth. The reason is that any merit that appears in any soul is only by the grace of God and not due to the greatness of the soul. Here, you must understand that truth is not praise.
17. Please answer on the following argument.
[Swami, another friend asked “Every incarnation of God does miracles, teaches knowledge and suffers the punishments of the sins of His devotees by taking on His own body. Nevertheless, only God Krishna is called as most completest incarnation. One extra thing done by God Krishna is Raasaleela, which is romance with many souls. With that one extra qualification of romancing with souls, Krishna became the most completest incarnation of God, is it?” Swami, please answer him.]
Swami replied:- Gopikas were sages, who are burning penance-fires. They have smashed lust in their penance fire. God Krishna is the infinite ocean of bliss, which is completely different from worldly happiness. The bliss is real and infinite in quantity. Worldly happiness is illusory and is not even a drop before the ocean of divine bliss. In this way, there is qualitative and quantitative difference between divine bliss and worldly happiness. If you say that God Krishna or sages craved for worldly happiness, anybody will laugh at your statement, not by mouth, but by anus! The raasa-dance preaches that the soul shall break all its worldly bonds for the sake of the bond with God and this is not mandatory, but optional! Sages craved for this divine opportunity since they prayed God Krishna in His previous birth when He was called by the name God Rama. If you don’t want this liberation from all worldly bonds, there is no force on you. You can lick the anuses of your spouse and children from whom you are going to be separated permanently by death in this birth!
18. What makes God greater than freedom fighters and social activists?
[Swami, another friend asked “Because God is omnipotent, He is able to create the entire world and run it on the lines of justice. Nobody is omnipotent and hence, they are not as great as God. If a good soul gets omnipotence, then he/she might do a better job than God. In fact, good souls like freedom fighters and social activists are doing a better job because they are fighting for justice without having any potential and risking their own lives. What makes God greater than these people?” Swami, please answer her.]
Swami replied:- The first reason for the greater greatness of God over these people is present in your own statement. God can destroy the injustice by His mere will whereas these people are fighting against injustice not winning every time even though they are taking risk of their lives. This itself proves that God is far far greater than these people. You may ask about the reason for God not punishing the unjust persons immediately. The first reason is that you do not know the background of all the previous births of all the souls in this creation. You don’t even know the sins done secretly by the person, who appears to you as a justified person externally. If X is harming Y, Y might have harmed X in the previous birth and this may be retorting action of God about which these people cannot do anything even on taking the risk of their lives. The second reason is that God gives some time for reformation to even a very bad soul. If you see the present judicial system, how much time they are taking for analysing the case before giving the judgement! Hence, your atheistic mentality is always hasty in nature with foolish and ignorant emotions.
19. Is God running the creation for His selfish entertainment?
[Swami, everyone here is saying that God is running this creation for His own selfish benefit of getting entertainment since He is bored with loneliness. Of course, they are agreeing that God is running this creation in the lines of justice. But, they are not agreeing to the fact that God has true love on souls since i) God created worldly bonds on temporary basis so that the bond with Him becomes permanent, ii) God gave free will to souls making everyone open to become victims for other’s sinful actions so that He becomes the saviour of souls due to His omnipotence, iii) God gives no option to souls to exit His creation like the Dictator of North Korea although God doesn’t force anyone to worship Him like that dictator and iv) He is a married man, who tests the spouse-bond of other married women, but, preaches everyone to follow the justice of maintaining one wife.]
Swami replied:- Even though God created this world for His entertainment, this entertainment is not like the sadistic entertainment of a husband burning the hands of his wife with his smoking cigarettes. A rich man started a college for his entertainment that can remove his loneliness. This is not wrong provided the rich man is running the college with all justified background like efficient staff, excellent laboratories, library etc.
i) The human beings are temporary due to the inevitable death. If death is absent, every soul will be continuously bored with this monotonous life and becomes mad. Hence, the bonds are temporary due to the inevitable concept of the background. Since God is eternal, the bond with Him is inevitably permanent.
ii) God did not give free will in the entire Satya Yuga, which is the longest. Then, the souls were very much bored by the continuous divine discipline and prayed God for free will. God gave free will with many instructions in the form of ethical scriptures for the protection of souls from the sins resulting due to free will. Therefore, there is no bad intention at all in the mind of God about this point. Due to the free will, souls violated the instructions of God and fell in the trap of problems, which are inevitable punishments of their own sins. Among such souls, who realised their mistakes and prayed God were saved by God. All your argument is just created foolishness due to your jealousy towards God.
iii) In North Korea, Mr. Kim does not allow his citizens to cross the boundaries of his country. This can be good provided he doesn’t torture them unnecessarily. But, Mr. Kim tortures the citizens unnecessarily. God does not torture any soul without the background of its bad deed. Moreover, God tries to save even the worst sinner through reformation that is developed through spiritual knowledge preached by Him in the form of human incarnation visiting earth in every generation. God doesn’t allow the soul to exit His creation and become non-existent because it is unimaginable horrible loss to the very soul itself.
iv) God always teaches justice to every soul to be with one wife or one husband. God Rama did this in excellent manner. The same Rama is incarnated as Krishna for the sake of sages, who did lot of penance for the sake of getting salvation from all the worldly bonds so that they can merge with God permanently. You, bloody fellow! You are blaming God without connecting the contribution of other side. A sick person went to a doctor and requested the doctor to give an injection that introduces powerful antibiotic medicine directly into the blood so that he can be cured immediately. According to the request of the patient, the doctor is giving the injection. Exactly at this time, you dirty fellow, enter the scene and scold the doctor for piercing the patient with a steel needle. You must go to a mental hospital and join it for your mental treatment.
★ ★ ★ ★ ★