
Posted on 02 Dec 2018. Share
Discourse Podcast
O Learned and Devoted Servants of God,
[Dr. C. Annapurna asked:- Please clarify once again the topic of “Indrashatru” mentioned in Veda, which is referred by You in the recent messages.]
Swami Replied:- The Vedic scholars of puurvamiimaamsas line say (Yathendrashatruh svaratoparaadhaat) that Vrutra-demon was killed because in the worship prayer on behalf of Vrutra, the sages (forced by Vrutra to do the prayer) changed the upper accent (Udaatta svara) to be used on the word ‘Shatro’ to the word ‘Indra’ so that the original meaning expected (that the enemy of Indra, who is Vrutra shall flourish) is changed to the opposite meaning (that Indra or the enemy of Vrutra shall flourish). This is the interpretation in support of the priests reciting the Veda blindly without knowing its meaning. This interpretation says that the meaning depends on the accent and hence, results are received without the reference of the knowledge of the Veda. By this, the priests attract people to support them for reciting the Veda without knowing its meaning since fruits are received by mere sound-accents used in the blind recitation.
Actually, the word ‘Indrashatru’ has two types of meanings based on the rules of Sanskrit grammar:-
1) Indra himself is the enemy (Indrashchaasau shatrushcha) and this is Prathamaatatpurusha samaasa and
2) The enemy of Indra, who is Vrutra (Indrasya shatruh) and this is Shashthiitatpurusha samaasa.
In the grammar, it is not told that the difference comes based on the accent. The difference comes as per the intension to take the meaning for this word. The above theory of accent means that irrespective of intension, meaning is decided by the accent. Such point is not mentioned by the grammar.
Let us assume that the priests had intension also about the favour to Indra and hence, the reverse result happened. If the result is based on the intension, then, there is no necessity of accent. If you say that both intension and accent together give the result, such concept is not found in the worships done by the priests in saying the intension or aim (Samkalpa) before doing the vedic or non-Vedic worship. In uttering the Samkalpa in the beginning, accent is not used, in which case results should not come. But, results are seen for the Samkalpa uttered without accent. In any type of worship (Vedic or non-Vedic), the Samkalpa is not from the Veda and hence, does not possess accent.
In fact, whether it is the Vedic worship or non-Vedic worship, Samkalpa is not from the Veda and hence, there is no point of accent. Actually, God gives fruits to the prayers done. The sanction of results by God is based on His independent discrimination. God is not giving results for the prayers based on the accent or the samkalpa (intension) of the praying devotee. If the prayer is justified, God gives positive result and if it is not justified, God keeps silent. Here, in this case, Vrutra is a bad demon and Indra is a good angel. God always supports good souls. Hence, God gave the reverse result by which Vrutra was killed by Indra and not the reverse. God is neither bound by the inert sound-accent nor bound by the non-inert intension of the soul in giving results mechanically bent by intension or accent.
In the above case of Indrashatru, God favoured Indra because Indra is a good soul. Incidentally, the accent in the prayer and the intension of sages coincided with the decision of God to support good side. This is called Kaakataaliiyaka nyaaya, which means that when a person stood under a palm tree, a crow also came and sat on it in the same time and a palm fruit fell on the person. The fruit fell on its own reason that its stem became very weak resulting in falling of the fruit. The person thought that since the crow sat on the tree, the fruit has fallen. This is just a coincidence of the sitting crow and fall of the fruit. Based on this, the priests exploited this coincidence in support of their blind recitation of the Veda without knowing or explaining its meaning.
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
Also Read
Correlation Of Vedic Statements
Posted on: 16/12/2022Does Homa To The God Of Fire Bring Wealth?
Posted on: 15/03/2024O Priests, Bring Glory To Yourselves
Posted on: 27/02/2010Does Self-praise Bring Sin And Ego?
Posted on: 20/07/2025Please Clarify Whether The Following Two Vedic Statements Mean The Same.
Posted on: 25/08/2025
Related Articles
What Is The Connection Between Theism And The Belief In The Veda?
Posted on: 29/02/2020Does The Sound Of Vedic Recitation Causing Glass To Break Prove The Veda's Supernatural Potency?
Posted on: 28/03/2020Swami Answers Questions By Smt. Priyanka
Posted on: 15/12/2022