home
Shri Datta Swami

 18 Oct 2025

 

If castes are based on the interested field, why abandoning parents lead to a candala birth?

[Ms. Kiranmai asked:- Padanamaskaram Swami! I read Shri Guru Charithra whenever I feel low, everytime I read I get stuck at one adhyayam where a Chandala recalls past lives after Shri Nrusimha Saraswati Swami places vibhuti on him. He learns he was once a Brahmin but is now born as a chandala, Swami tells the reason is due to abandoning his parents. If castes are formed out of the interest in a field one chooses, why did Swami gave this discriminated justification? Why did Swami answer like this.]

Swami replied:- The qualities and deeds decide the caste and not the birth as told in the Gita. When Swami addressed a person as caṇḍāla in the current birth, the word ‘caṇḍāla’ indicates the worst life of a sinner and not by birth. Due to the sinful deed of rejecting his parents, he became a sinner in the past life and continuing to live the sinful life without reformation even in this birth. If he gets reformed and never repeats the sin in future, he will no longer be called as ‘caṇḍāla’. God says in the Gita that He has created only four castes based on professional qualities and deeds such as Brahmana, Kshatriya, Vaishya and Shudra (Cāturvarṇyaṃ mayā sṛṣṭam). This 5th caste called caṇḍāa was formed much later when the sinners belonging to all the four castes were expelled from their respective castes in the village because of the sins committed by them. This expulsion was done to bring some reformation in the sinners and not for taking revenge on them. The word ‘caṇḍāla’ means cruelty and anger. Irrespective of gender, any person, who is cruel, can be called as caṇḍāla. The son or daughter of a caṇḍāla cannot be called as caṇḍāla because every soul is different and children should not be punished for the sins done by their parents. The omniscient God has created the caste system based on professional qualities and deeds for the perfect functioning of the society (Guṇakarma vibhāgaśaḥ - Gita). The ignorant and cunning human beings created a caste system based on birth to divide the society following Hinduism. Therefore, God told in the Gita that He is not responsible for the caste system based on birth (Viddhyakartāra mavyayam).

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

 
 whatsnewContactSearch